COMMON LAW RELATIONSHIPS & WILLS
Having a valid will in place is no doubt important for anyone, but more so for a common law spouse. In this article I will explain the different treatment for married and common law spouses on death. After reading this, I guarantee you will not have a good night’s sleep until your wills drafted and signed!
For married spouses, the major disadvantages to dying without a will (intestate) are 1) the mess that you leave for your loved ones and 2) not being in control of who gets what. The legislated “intestacy distribution” may not be what you think it is! In Ontario, your spouse will receive the first $200,000 of your estate and the spouse and your children will share the rest equally.
If you are in a common-law relationship, however, this legislated distribution DOES NOT APPLY. The law does NOT treat married spouses and common law spouses the same regarding entitlement of assets on death. Common-law spouses are not automatically entitled to assets on death the way married spouses are.
Nor are common law spouses entitled to make an “equalization” claim against the estate. If a person dies without a will, their married spouse has the option of choosing their inheritance. They can allow the intestacy distribution to apply as described above. Or, a second option is to elect instead an equalization payment out of the estate. The amount available here would be half of the “net family assets”. This option generates a result similar to the equalization payment in a separation or divorce situation.
What options do common law spouses have on death where no will exists? Any option involves hiring a lawyer to take the estate to court – a costly and unpleasant event! They can claim for support from the estate IF they can prove that they were financially dependent on the deceased. This is the same right afforded anyone who was dependent on the deceased. Very often dependent children would step ahead in line of a dependent common law spouse. The other option is to argue that the deceased was actually holding property in trust for the survivor. Of course, this is a strong argument if the assets have been paid for -or partially paid for – out of the survivor’s pocket!
Due to the lack of legislation at this time to protect common law spouses on death, it is imperative that they have valid wills to protect each other’s interests. Having a will removes the possibility that one is left penniless on the death of their common law spouse. For both married and common law spouses, owning property as joint tenants, and completing the beneficiary designations for insurance policies, RRSPs and other registered pension plans are other ways of ensuring your loved one is provided for.
While every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of this article, it is not intended to provide legal advice as individual situations will differ and should be discussed with an expert and/or lawyer. For specific technical or legal advice on the information provided and related topics, please contact the author.
By Maureen C. Tabuchi, LL.B,MTAX

